Film |
Rating
(out of 4 stars) |
Comments |
| Note: All my future movie reviews will be posted straight to my weblog, and eventually I'll probably just transition this page over to a weblog format. It's lower maintenance, and I should really just index all these anyhow. You can find them by just going to the movies category page of my weblog. |
| All About Lily Chou-Chou (2001) |
 |
|
| Breathless (1961) |
 |
|
| Van Helsing (2004) |
 |
I walked out of the theater with my clothes tattered, hair mussed, bleeding from the lip. Unfortunately, it wasn't the result of a tussle with Kate Beckinsale's corset. No, I had been assaulted by Stephen Sommers's monstrosity of a movie and beaten to a pulp. |
Step into Liquid (2003)
|
 |
Yo, dude, I got the stoke. Surfers as talking heads are not a good idea, but footage of them riding big waves is awesome. Laird Hamilton and buddies invented some crazy contraption called the foil board. It's sick!
|
| Zatoichi: Darkness is his Ally (1989) |
 |
|
| Zatoichi (2003) |
 |
Takeshi Kitano's take on Japan's legendary blind samurai Zatoichi. Kitano seems to believe, as I do, that the idea of Zatoichi--a blind, unparalleled swordsman, masseur, sometime pervert--is ridiculous, and so he has some fun with the character. He should have had more fun, in my estimation. The movie palette is muted, Kitano's Zatoichi is strangely cruel and heartless, and the storyline is needlessly grim. |
| Tube (2003) |
 |
A Hollywood movie went out into the world, traveled to Korea, got assimilated and regurgitated, and now it returns to our shores as this. The studios know it and advertise it as the Korean Speed. It also "borrows" a score straight from Hans Zimmer's work for The Rock, and the main actor looks like Chow Yun Fat light. It's discouraging to see Korean cinema paying homage to American action flicks--is this what we've spawned?
On the other hand, this movie composite of so many action movies we've seen before is fascinating in its skewed familiarity, like listening to E.T. after he learned to speak English from watching television. It's not terrible; the production values are high. I think of it as top notch karaoke, like American Idol. In the proper context, it's impressive. |
| The Return (2004) |
 |
My review. |
| Infernal Affairs III (2003) |
 |
Slightly confusing but otherwise satisfying conclusion to perhaps the definitive Hong Kong cops and robbers trilogy. |
| Kill Bill Vol. 2 (2004) |
 |
|
| House of Sand and Fog (2003) |
 |
Credible adaptation of Andre Dubus's novel, but in the novel the most interesting drama is interior, drama the movie can only allude to with broad gestures. Efforts to establish the house as a character are a bit much; everytime it appears in long shot, fog skirts the house with menace and a heavy-handed score screams tragedy. |
| Something's Gotta Give (2003) |
 |
This little ditty about Jack and Diane works as a broad comedy. Not particularly profound, but Nicholson and Keaton are a joy to watch on screen.
The commentary by Jack is a hoot. |
| Hellboy (2004) |
 |
|
| Honey (2003) |
 |
The script is terrible, the acting and dancing
uninspiring, and the entire premise hokey and predictable. But
Jessica Alba's midriff is spectacular and deserves roles in stronger
movies. |
| Shattered Glass (2003) |
 |
The early third of this movie fails to set up
the characters and situation with any adequate depth, dampening
the impact of the payoff that comes later. Why does Stephen Glass
make up all these stories (including those he wrote for his first
editor Michael Kelly)? Why do the other editors despise Chuck Lane?
Is there a director's cut of this movie that solves these gaping
problems?
Fortunately, the payoff itself is such a spectacular
automobile crash of human denial that the schadenfreude itself
leaves the viewer with a pleasing buzz, like that from a cheap red
wine. When Hayden Christensen (Glass) and Peter Sarsgaard (Lane)
finally come to a boil, a movie that was to that point undercooked
suddenly achieves a nice, golden crisp. |
| Assassination Tango (2003) |
 |
Two plotlines meet in an empty dance hall. One
is about an assassin played by Robert Duvall who is sent to Argentina
on one last hit. The other is about how, while in Buenos Aires,
this assassin takes tango lessons from a beautiful young dancer
named Manuela (played by Duvall's real-life girlfriend Luciana
Pedraza). They try and dance together, but neither is sure who's
supposed to lead, so they stagger around clumsily, stepping on
each other's toes.
Duvall is clearly entranced by the tango and
by Pedraza--he should have stepped in and kicked out the assassin
plotline and simply asked for a dance with Pedraza. She's not
a professional actor, and yet her uncomplicated dialogue and
acting
provide the most natural and beguiling material that this movie
needs more of. |
| The Ladykillers (2004) |
 |
The Man Who Wasn't There, Intolerable Cruelty, and now this. The Coen brothers are on some sort of genre homage kick, but it's a waste of their talent. The thick layers of genre dressings are burying their unique genius.
Films like Raising Arizona and Fargo and The Big Lebowski accustomed us to expect off-beat comic rhythms. When we're presented with the conventional comic timing of The Ladykillers, it's shocking in its banality. I half expected to hear the old drum beat after each punchline (ba-doom-boom, <cymbal crash>).
|
| Sylvia (2003) |
 |
Depicting mental illness and bringing poetry to life are always going to be huge challenges for movies. The life interior doesn't lend itself well to translation into the literal visual language of film. It's too much of a challenge for Sylvia to overcome, despite a gallant effort by Gwynelth Paltrow. She's so strong she overwhelms co-star Ted Craig. |
| Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004) |
 |
Some kind of brilliant! |
| Spartan (2004) |
 |
Some people find David Mamet's directing style tiresome. He has all his actors read their lines as if they're reciting a grocery list. But Mamet's lines, even read deadpan, speak for themselves. He inserts more zingers per minute of dialogue than any screenwriter I can think of, and I chuckle at the audacity and bravado of some of them. The line readings also fit with Mamet's obsession with artifice and the art of the con. Actors are merely highly paid con men, and so why shouldn't they acknowledge that by reading their lines as if they were reading off cue cards? The greatest con men can pull off the gig even when they tell you it's coming, so why not actors? |
| The
Passion of the Christ (2004) |
 |
Those in the audience who aren't well-versed in
the Gospels and the story and characters of the Passion will |
| Freddy vs. Jason (2003) |
 |
Freddy laments at the start of the movie that he no longer holds sway over the youths on Elm Street because they've forgotten about him. Watching this silliness, I could see why. He's lost his claws and become a crowd-pleaser. Listening to him reading hammy lines is like watching a formerly fearsome grizzly sitting back and begging for treats like some circus animal.
Fans of both original series may enjoy exorcising their childhood demons by watching this movie and laughing at the thought of ever having been haunted by these two. |
| The Fog of War (2003) |
 |
Perhaps it's only once politicians are out of the cauldron of Washington D.C. that they can speak honestly. An honest politician may be the most intriguing species of honest man if only because we're curious to see what's under that shell which calcified over dozens of years in office? |
| Starsky and Hutch (2004) |
 |
I wrote before that it would be either glorious or gloriously bad.
It was the latter. In the beginning was an idea:
hey, wouldn't it be funny if Ben Stiller and Owen Wilson played
Starsky and Hutch? Around that single wall an entire flimsy house
of unfunny gags was erected. |
| Runaway Jury (2003) |
 |
The concept seems to fit these times: corporations
are able to subvert the law by capitalizing on the services of
jury-riggers like
Gene Hackman who use surveillance and investigation to both predict
and control each juror's vote. Gun manufacturers, sued by the widow
of a lawyer gunned down by an office psycho, call on Hackman
to assist their attorney. Little do they realize that Rachel
Weisz
and John Cusack are also working the jury from the other side.
In the end, if the good guys triumph (yes, this is a liberal
Hollywood movie so the gun mfrs are clearly the black hats),
we're perhaps
left with the message that even good guys have to play dirty
to win. A depressing but cutting message.
Instead, the movie ends by telling us the jury
arrived at their verdict purely of their own free will. Yet when
the jury deliberation scene ends, one has no idea how
John Cusack will turn one of the other jurors, a former military
leader, to his side. None of the other jurors offer any interesting
insights on the case except to shout phrases like "That's bulls***!"
The entire scene both undermines one's faith in the legal system
and fails to convince us that the jurors did any thinking of their
own. And what of all the cases beyond this one? Hackman and his
cohort show no signs of disappearing at movie's end, casting
a pall over the supposed happy ending.
Another problem is that because the audience is
privy to the behind-the-scenes machinations, the usually dramatic
courtroom speeches and cross-examinations are stripped of all
import. Dustin Hoffman rants and raves and we wonder why he's
wasting his breath.
Grisham
adaptations are surprisingly slick, though. For someone whose
books are routinely dismissed as schlock,
Grisham makes sure to deliver the type of material that's easily
transformed into glitzy Hollywood schlock. Just defrost and microwave. |
| In America (2003) |
 |
Director Jim Sheridan taps his personal experiences to extract
the spirit of the American immigrant, the courage and perseverance
it takes to bring your family to a foreign land with just the
change in your
pocket.
That he pours this spirit into an oddly innocuous New York slum
of an apartment (the immigrant family of the movie has as its support
cocoon a network of panhandlers, drug dealers, AIDS patients, and
waitresses) is forgivable. Nostalgia can reflect even tragedy as
something glorious.
At such close quarters and in such heavy doses, immigrant spirit
can leave one drunk with tears and laughter. I would have preferred
some room for the the whole mix to breathe and to see more of NYC
and America itself, mostly rendered here as a few long shots of
the Manhattan skyline. Sheridan stays locked in tightly to his actors.
It's truly an ensemble of five that, more than the setting
or the script, that carry the entire movie. But when
the acting is so natural and sublime, especially by child actors
and real-life
sisters
Sarah
and Emma
Bolger, the
emotions all go down smooth, leaving a pleasant warmth inside. |
| Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance (2002) |
 |
The story is familiar: revenge begets revenge, no one is left untouched.
In this case, neither is the viewer. |
| Infernal Affairs 2 (2003) |
 |
Was this film conceived of after the success of
Infernal Affairs? If so, then it's all the more impressive for
expanding the scope
of the original story. This is a prequel that expands our enjoyment
of both movies by burrowing cones of history
behind all of the characters while broadening
the sweep of the story. The Infernal Affairs series is
shaping up to be Godfather-light of Hong Kong cinema. Supposedly
Martin Scorsese and Leonardo Dicaprio are looking
at remaking it. |
| Intolerable
Cruelty (2003) |
 |
Both pleasant and mildly farcical when it could
have been joyous or sharply satirical, or both. Some comic high
moments, especially
from Billy Bob Thornton and a hit man nicknamed Wheezy Joe. But a
lot of the humor cuts like a butter knife, and a dull one at that,
and though George Clooney and Catherine Zeta-Jones (gorgeous, as
usual) gamely play the dueling leads, the movie contains as much
love and emotion
as a marriage
bound by a pre-nup. |
| Touching
the Void (2004) |
 |
Mountain climbing has always struck me as one
of the craziest and purest manifestations of human courage, ambition,
and arrogance. This quasi-documentary (in this past year, with
movies
like American Splendor and this one, we've developed
the need for a new term for documentaries that mix fiction and
non-fiction
in equal doses) shows us just how pure the sport distills these
human traits.
In 1985, Simon Yates and Joe Simpson, two bold
twenty-something climbers, attempted to become the first climbers
to summit the West Face of the Siula Grande mountain in the
Andes in Peru. They made it up fine, but on the way down, disaster
struck, and the two would be forced to make decisions that perhaps
neither was ready for.
The mixture of interview footage with Simpson
and Yates, mixed with the dramatization of the events by actors
and a film crew in the Andes, is partially successful. The real-life
Simpson and Yates dominate the emotional drama as the actors
speak little and focus on acting out the climbing itself. The
effect is similar to the emotional displacement one experiences
while watching re-enactments of crimes on Unsolved Mysteries,
though the actors here are put through much greater peril. The
movie also strays into some interpretive stylistic affectations
at the end which seem amateurish; it's most effective when it
hews to the unobtrusive documentary style.
The movie doesn't cover delve into the controversy
around Yates fateful decision, nor does it offer an epilogue
on the friendship. Such an incredible story begs for such exposition,
some of which can be found in the bestselling book by
Simpson. |
| Capturing
the Friedmans (2003) |
 |
Andrew Jarecki set out to make a documentary about birthday
clowns, and he ended up making Capturing the Friedmans, which is
like setting
out to find the next island over and discovering America. During
Thanksgiving 1987, police raid the home of the Long Island family
the Friedmans and discover a stash of child pornography belonging
to the father, Arnold. Soon both Arnold and his 18 year old middle
son Jesse are arrested on charges of child molestation during computer
classes given at the Friedman home by Arnold, a high school science
teacher. But Jarecki discovers a remarkable hidden treasure of
additional evidence: oldest son David, the birthday clown, videotaped
almost all of the key events during this tumultuous period in their
lives, even family arguments.
The documentary covers so much ground: the innocence of
young love,
the
dissolution
of a family and marriage, the fallibility of the legal system,
a community's deep repulsion of child molestation, real or imagined,
and more. Yet even with all this footage, we are left uncertain of
the truth. The camera records the reverberations of the alleged events
pulsing out in every direction, tearing apart this family, and
we are left wondering how the courts could dole out justice with
such certainty. |
| Once Upon a Time in Mexico (2003) |
 |
Felt like a cubist retrospective of El Mariachi and Desperado,
with a random entertaining cameo by Johnny Depp in one of his
I'm-going-to-act-however-I-wish performances. |
| Spellbound (2002) |
 |
A documentary following eight children in their
quest to capture the National Spelling Bee. As 9 million spellers
across the country are whittled down to one, we feel the power
of the American Dream inspiring and infecting all of the nation's
varied citizens. Thoroughly charming and suspenseful. |
| Millennium Actress (2002) |
 |
An aging actress looks back on her career with
a television interviewer. This is anime that doesn't involve robotic
warriors, science fiction,
the future, sex change, demons, pornography. One begins to see some
of the limitations of the anime style, especially the blunt communicative
force of the exaggerated facial expressions, but some stylistic
quirks, like the stillness of the images, lend the story a poetic,
haiku-like feel. |
| The Company (2004) |
 |
A fictional movie, yet it feels like a documentary:
its plot is held so lightly in the hand it seems to slip through
one's hands
like sand, yet by movie's end we have a panoramic understanding
of life in Chicago's Joffrey Ballet. On the other hand, the movie's
dialogue and editing make less of an
attempt
at assembling
into
a linear
plot
or tracing
a discernible
dramatic
path than even the roughest of documentaries. The movie feels like
a multi-layered composition, dozens of stories overlapping, criss-crossing,
starting and ending mid-stream.
Most of the dancing is beautiful, filmed in a
gauzy haze, and the sounds of the fabric and human bodies as
they slide
and
bounce against the stage are a feast for the ears. Malcom McDowell
is humorous as the company director, and Neve Campbell is convincing
as one of the star dancers. The most organic movie one will see
in years; those who go to the theater to be manipulated may be
disappointed. |
| The Machinist (2004) |
 |
|
| Miracle (2004) |
 |
Feels like an old-school Disney feel-good story.
In other words, it's fairly conservative in characterizations and
plotting, hinting at the dark sides of the 1980 U.S. Olympic team's
success but retreating from all of them. The in-game shots are
disappointing; the camera seems trapped between the players,
without
enough distance
to discern
overall patterns,
and the effect is claustrophobic.
It's difficult, in the end, to completely mishandle
such a ready-made fairy tale. The movie attempts at giving the event
an integral place in history at the time, showing montages of
clips from the Cold War, but the movie is most convincing when
it |
| American
Wedding (2003) |
 |
Those in creative control did not love these characters, and it
shows on screen. This one tears exploits and taints the otherwise
endearing gang we met and grew to know in the first two movies. |
| Ping Pong (2002) |
 |
|
| Les
Triplettes de Belleville (2003) |
 |
In this animated adventure, a young European boy, groomed to compete
in the Tour de France by his grandmother(?), is kidnapped and brought
across
the
ocean
to a fictional town called Belleville, clearly a stand-in for New
York City.
All the strengths and weaknesses of caricature.
On the one hand, the
exaggerated
details
amuse: the
cleft
that cyclists
have
in their
calves, contrasted against their emaciated upper bodies; the
gargantuan, overweight American; the broad shouldered mafia henchman.
On the
other hand, none of the characterizations go much beyond hyperbolic
physical details or colorful mannerisms. The unique animation style
and music will get your toes tapping, but this movie can't match
up to
your average episode of The Simpsons for cleverness and bite. |
| Destino (2003) |
 |
A collaboration of two mad geniuses, Walt Disney
and Salvador Dali, produced this entrancing animated short. This
is Dali's version of Fantasia, complete with all the most iconic
of his images: melting clocks, human forms assembled from stone
and empty space, vast desert plains. As much hallucinatory visual
tickling as one can experience without the use of recreational
drugs. |
| Big Fish (2003) |
 |
A great disappointment. A movie about a father (on his deathbed
he's played by Albert Finney and in flashbacks by Ewan McGregor)
who tells nothing but tall tales, over and over again, and the
son (Billy Crudup) who wants the truth. The real tall tale is the
thought
that a Tim Burton movie could nearly
put
me to
sleep with it's bland fantasies. Burton usually tickles with his
wacky but unmistakeably sensibility and style, that of the drama
club recluse who also happens to enjoy dissecting animals in biology
class. Here his vision seems wrapped in gauze. Even the Danny Elfman
score is flat, listless.
|
| Girl
With a Pearl Earring (2003) |
 |
It's an interesting exercise, to try and imagine
what inspired Vermeer's famous painting, Girl
with a Pearl Earring. Interesting, but not altogether successful.
Scarlett Johansson plays Griet, the maid who inspires the painting,
and Colin Firth plays Vermeer. Johansson proves up to the task
of a mostly silent part, subtly conveying through her face and
body
language what most young actresses of her generation would pull
muscles attempting. The scenes in which she and Firth work together
in his studio are enjoyable unions of kindred artistic sensibilities.
Johansson and Firth are well-suited to portraying such taciturn
longing as both of them smolder below the surface. A shot of their
two faces under a piece of cloth as they peer into a camera
obscura
is beautifully
lit
and
framed.
But, just as our historical knowledge of the motivation
for this painting is thin, so is the movie's plot. Around the
idea of the
relationship between Griet and Vermeer, the screenplay has added
unconvincing period melodrama that in turn inspires some unpleasant
overacting. Tom Wilkinson's character is especially guilty, stopping
just short of donning a handlebar mustache. Oh wait, he does
don a handlebar mustache.
Gorgeous score by Alexandre Desplat. |
| Nowhere
in Africa (2002) |
 |
|
| The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003) |
 |
|
| The Cooler (2003) |
 |
William Macy plays the Cooler, hired by Alec Baldwin's
casino owner to cool off gamblers on a hot streak. How does he
do that? Simply
by standing near them and bringing them into his halo of incredibly
bad luck. The movie has a lot of fun with this premise, and so does
the audience. The story built around this idea isn't quite as strong,
but it does offer Alec Baldwin in one of his raging alpha-male
modes, and that's always a treat. |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003) |
 |
The most exhilarating experience I've had in
a movie theater in ages. I've spent so many hours watching and
rewatching the previous
two chapters, so the emotional payoffs of the third were that much
more rewarding. It's an awesome visual spectacle as well. With
the books and the worldwide legions of fans of this tale, it's
difficult
to imagine another fantasy epic surpassing this one for many, many
decades.
The phrase "working your heart out" applies here. Jackson and
everyone involved worked their heart out, and it landed on the
screen for all to see. |
| Bruce Almighty (2003) |
 |
In this movie, Bruce Nolan (Jim Carrey) is granted
the powers of God, and all he can think of doing with them is to
advance his own career at a local television news station. Step
back through the movie screen and what you have is a director who
had the idea to make a movie about a normal guy granted the powers
of God, except the normal guy would be played by Jim Carrey, his
girlfriend by Jennifer Anistron, and God by Morgan Freeman, and
yet all the director could do was to make this silly Groundhog
Day-style parable.
To capitalize on Jim Carrey, you have to
set him free. Here, he's asked to simply rehash the same physical
gags he can do in his sleep in the service of a childish morality
tale.
|
| Lara
Croft Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life (2003) |
 |
Angelina Jolie captures the speech and physical mannerisms of the
video game character quite well. Unfortunately, video game characters
have no real personality or motivations, and she captures that as
well. |
| 21 Grams (2003) |
 |
Unfortunately for a movie that is supposed to
be unflinching in its depiction of reality, the director, Alejandro
Gonzalez Iñarritu,
flinched. Instead of showing us a story in a straightforward, linear
chronology, he throws bits and pieces of a story at us from all
over the timeline. It's a stylistic mistake that subtracts more
than it
adds, robbing the story of narrative momentum. I felt like I was
picking up shards of glass from an explosion, trying to piece them
together. Unfortunately, long after enough pieces had been assembled
to understand the storyline, I still had to sit and watch as the
final pieces were put into place.
I often hear Iñarritu praised as a gritty realist,
but while he clearly hasn't been polluted by Hollywood groupthink,
he is hardly
a realist. His bold stylistic choices, from his shaky handheld shots
to the grainy film stock to the sickly color palettes to the extreme
closeups, paired with his unbelievable storylines, mark him as
anything but a
realist.
Some of the shards stand alone as absorbing vignettes, but
Iñarritu's fever rubs off on Naomi Watts who's forced into
intense but overwrought hysterics. Benicio del Toro and Sean Penn
create complex, nuanced characters, but they drown in a tragedy that
is audio amplified to the point of static and feedback. |
| The Last Samurai (2003) |
 |
Edward Zwick plots and directs in cinematic
shorthand, and he knows it well. When he's directing stories
of an almost
mythological nature,
like Legends
of the Fall, his broad brushstrokes feel appropriately
impressionistic. Zwick's The Last Samurai, however, feels
blurry. The story's animating forces are Tom Cruise's gradual conversion
to the samurai way of life and the clash between that way of life
and the modernizing Western forces invading Japan, but neither
is described in enough detail. It doesn't help that the enemies
are
cartoonishly cowardly, evil, and weak as compared to the noble samurai.
The counterbalance, though, are the wonderful
performances of the Samurai villagers, from Ken Watanabe as the
samurai Katsumoto to Hiroyuki Sanada as Ujio; both have wonderfully
stern faces. Hans Zimmer delivers his usual driving martial themes
to complement the immaculate cinematography of John Toll (ah! New
Zealand!), both in the service of straightforward but easy-to-follow
battle scenes. An early sneak attack on the samurai, with ninja-like
assassins swarming the village, left the audience clapping with
joy. I never once believed it was Japan--it looked like a movie
set--but Zwick has never been a realist, and some of my favorite
movies like The Untouchables resemble our collective dream of
what a certain era must have been like.
Tom Cruise doesn't ever seem to inhabit a character;
you can feel his effort and concentration and intensity in every
scene, but it feels like the energy of professional movie star
Tom Cruise and not that particular character. But he's worked
with nearly all the great directors going today, and I suspect
it's not just his professionalism. Directors can drape any action
plot over Cruise, and his sheer intensity seems to lend it credibility
and energy. |
| Love Actually (2003) |
 |
The trailer portended that this would be a romantic comedy to end
all romantic comedies, from the reigning king of the genre, Richard
Curtis. Instead, it is the romantic comedy that is all romantic comedies;
all that is missing is Julia Roberts. Nearly every stock romantic
comedy premise is here, crammed into one movie. It's as if Curtis
couldn't decide which story to direct next, so he decided to do all
of them in abbreviated form. There's unrequited love, unexpected
love, cheating hearts, love triangles, puppy love, rebound romances
for lonely divorcees, presidential romances, buddy sentiment, and
so on.
I'm not a romantic comedy fan, not because I'm
a curmudgeon, but because most instances of the genre offer such
ridiculous fantasies that teach nothing. Love Actually is
guilty of such occasional silliness (it opens with a comment from
Hugh Grant's British Prime Minister about Sept. 11 that needed to
be cut), but much of it won me over (I'm not just referring to the
presence of the dreamy Keira Knightley). The cast is first-rate,
and I enjoyed watching them work, from Hugh Grant's usual rakish
charmer to Colin Firth's self-doubting romantic. And not all the
stories end happily--too much sugar will ruin even the richest of
desserts. |
| Anger Management (2003) |
 |
After I saw this,
I wanted to see this.
How embarrassing for everyone involved. |
| Master and Commander (2003) |
 |
Unlike, say, Tom Cruise or Sean Penn, Russell
Crowe's intensity seems to be channelled entirely towards the
recreation
of the character
he's playing. His Captain Jack Aubrey is a convincingly salty commander.
I have not read the O'Brian books, so I cannot review the movie
from
the
perspective
of its
faithfulness
to its
source
material. But on its own, Peter Weir's movie is an immensely
satisfying sea adventure and character study. Paul Bettany and
Max Pirkis
join Crowe in giving a triangle of thrillingly nuanced performances.
Many I've spoken to have said the movie felt slow.
I can't understand what they were hoping for! The shots of the
ship on the ocean are gorgeous (the CGI shots are near seamless),
the tension among the ship's crew palpable, and by movie's end,
you'll both understand what hardships the men on board had to endure
and wish you had been there to serve under Captain Jack. Crowe
pronounces to his men "This ship is England" and by movie's end
you understand him. |
| Elf (2003) |
 |
Just a short while into this movie, I felt that
something wasn't right. And then it dawned on me. This comedy
was playing its premise
(Will Ferrell is a human raised as one of Santa's elves) straight,
as sincere a Christmas movie as It's a Wonderful Life,
or Miracle
on 34th St. In this day and age of wink-wink satire, that
feels strange, especially when starring Will Ferrell. Certainly,
he's very good
at committing to his roles, and as always he never breaks form
in this movie: he's an elf from start to end. The cast around
Ferrell also stays in character throughout, showing remarkable
restraint.
But, unlike classic Christmas movies, this one
didn't contain any authentic revelations of where the Christmas spirit
is wanting. Sure, perhaps NYC could use some good cheer after the
past two years, but the New Yorkers in the movie don't seem particularly
cynical. And James Caan's conversion from cold-hearted businessman
to devoted family man is too trite to be moving. Take those stop-action
Rudolph Christmas specials as an example. Now those were Christmas
magic. A few of the inhabitants from
those TV specials, like Frosty the snowman, make an appearance
in Elf, and I immediately
wanted to rent those on DVD to get me in the mood for Xmas. |
| The Matrix Revolutions (2003) |
 |
The Matrix Reloaded stretched
the entire Matrix metaphor to its limits, and this concluding
chapter, while it concludes
all the action,
leaves all sorts of metaphorical threads dangling. Those devoting
their lives to the philosophical interpretation of the Matrix mythology
will need to do most of the work on this one. The production values
of the battle scenes are first-rate. After the concluding
fight, can kung-fu fighting on screen really go any higher? Still,
CGI has improved to the point where even the craziest fight scenes
fail to inspire the awe they once did. And all the CGI in the world
won't add 2nd and 3rd dimensions to the characters, all of whom
display rigid personalities and speech patterns.
If the Wachowski brothers had simply stopped after The
Matrix,
it could have stood alone just fine. But they built two giant skyscrapers
next to it, each costing more and utilizing the latest in technologies
and materials, but both lack the charm and inspiration of the original,
and the neighborhood now looks overcrowded. I look forward, though,
to the next project from the Wachowskis. They are talented and ambitious,
and with a blank page to work off of and no preconceived notions,
they can let their imaginations roam free again. |
| 28 Days (2003) |
 |
Anyone who has read The
Hot Zone or other accounts of
real-life battles with lethal viruses like Ebola will realize that
the truth in such
cases
is much more horrifying than the fictional scenario in this movie.
And a movie which seems to start as an interesting exploration
of how humans behave under such condensed Darwinian pressures
ends up, disappointingly, as simply another instance of the good
guys getting off the island. Even in Survivor the contestants
lose even if they win.
But some fun is had with conceits
like the 20 seconds one has to
act before
the
virus
turns infected
victims
into rabid
zombies. The DVD's alternate endings, especially the one never
filmed, turn out to be more interesting than the one that made
it into
theaters. |
| Comedian (2002) |
 |
More entertaining than a recent show he gave is this documentary
following Jerry Seinfeld in his return to stand-up after his long
and successful TV run. Exposes the neurotic tension and courage and
insecurities that lie behind the desire to get on stage and try to
make others laugh. A whole fraternity of guest stars, from Bill Cosby
to Chris Rock to Colin Quinn to Garry Shandling chat with Jerry and
nod knowingly at both why he's returning to the stage (after all,
he's got more money in the bank than he'll ever be able to spend)
and why such a big name is sweating performances in front of tiny
crowds in dark comedy clubs across the country.
Shot on a pair of camcorders, the editing is often distracting
and the soundtrack of lounge songs often obscures the dialogue,
but it's a faithful documentary of this very special art form.
Helped explain to me why Seinfeld went with so much old or repeat
material in his recent performance, and he comes off looking like
a relative saint as compared to the unknown, insecure, arrogant,
and neurotic comedian Orny Adams to whom he's contrasted throughout. |
| Russian
Ark (2002) |
 |
I can confirm what everyone has said--this film
is shot in one uninterrupted 96 minute take, wandering through
the Hermitage Museum
in St. Petersburg, one that is inhabited by ghosts from Russia's
history. Give
that cameraman a bonus and an appointment with a chiropractor.
Reminded me in ways of the magical control over the viewer's perspective
exerted by the motorized seats in Disney's Haunted Mansion,
but the lack of physical bodily motion enhances the dream-like
feel. I was in a trance for most of it, aided by the somewhat mumbled
conversation between the voice-over narrator (the voice of the
director, Alexander Sokurov?) and the French Marquis the camera
follows through the museum. At movie's end, after a stunning
ball in the grand ballroom, I felt a great sadness, and I wasn't
even entirely sure why; the
movie
had worked
on
me on subconscious levels.
Likely to be appreciated even more by greater
Russophiles than myself--I had
to
read some
articles
and
watch certain portions over to understand who certain historical
characters were, undermining the impact of letting the movie
wash over me in an uninterrupted flow. Perhaps this problem
was confined
to simply the DVD, but at times I could
not
tell who
was
speaking.
The
spacing
and direction
of the
dialogue was murky. It adds to the dream-like feel but also confused
some of the ideas being conveyed. |
| Kill Bill Vol.
1 (2003) |
 |
Stylistically dazzling, a faithful homage to
the bloody martial arts revenge flicks I saw growing up. The anime
sequence is a perfect stylistic choice, the set design is gorgeous,
the soundtrack toe-tappingly good, and Go-Go Yubari a hilarious
synthesization of all that's weird and insane about Japanese culture.
Still, Tarantino threatens with this picture to
become a belletrist of a moviemaker. While he captures pitch-perfect
the kinetic rage of martial arts revenge flicks, like those of the
Shaw Brothers, those movies always worked best as cult showpieces,
off on the fringes. Kill Bill Vol. 1 feels like Tarantino's entire
self-referential movie universe, informed by his own influences
from among his encyclopic catalog of movie plots and images and
esoteria, exploded onto 35 millimeter film. It looks like so much
insect debris on the windshield, but damn if it isn't colorful. |
| Mystic
River (2003) |
 |
Sean Penn remains one of the most fascinating
American actors going today, and his performance will burn a
hole in your
head. The entire cast dazzles, from a haunted Tim Robbins to
a frightened
Marcia Gay Harden to a steely Laura Linney (who gives a speech
in the tradition of wives who stand by their men through all
their
sins, the last being Amanda Peet in Changing Lanes).
The movie has the dramatic intensity of a play,
thanks in part to the still and unflinching gaze of Clint Eastwood's
camera (he's at his best when he doesn't resort to the obviously
lyrical moments, like the name half-inscripted into the cement,
or the overhead shot of Sean Penn raging in grief at his daughter's
murder, or the parade at movie's end). The gray hues evoke the
somber mood of both the main characters and
the
Boston
neighborhood
they're
trapped
in.
Mystic
River finds,
in this American working class milieu, a malaise that infects
one generation after another. It doesn't just arise from the
single incident at the beginning of the movie but seems to have
infected the entire neighborhood. |
| The
Italian Job (2003) |
 |
I could stare at Charlize Theron for days and
not get tired of the view. Just stunningly beautiful.
Caper flicks may be one of the last types of the
action genre fun enough to watch because, despite knowing the outcome,
you're curious to see how they pull it off. This is one of the better
examples of that genre because it grins the whole way. Hot cars
(Aston Martin's and BMW Mini Coopers; this is the most expensive
of the BMWFilms), Venice, Charlize Theron, gold bricks, Armani suits,
and sexy music. The only unpleasant image in this movie is Ed Norton's
hideous mustache.
Side note: The last time Donald Sutherland was
in Venice was in Don't
Look Now, which, despite a naked tussle involving Julie
Christie, gave me nightmares for a long time. This was a much more
pleasant visit. |
| The Rundown
(2003) |
 |
I never thoughd I'd write this, but The Rundown
manages to spoil a good performance by The Rock. It's not quite Olivier,
but The Rock looks like a giant befuddled gorilla when he scowls,
and he plays an admirable straight man to Sean William Scott's overacting.
Who wrote Stifler, err, Scott's lines? They're so incredibly unfunny
they drain all the fun out of this picture because Scott dominates
the dialogue. Even another in a long line of wacky cameos from Christopher
Walken can't save this from being as colorful and unpleasant as a
baboon's ass. |
| Matchstick
Men (2003) |
 |
Strange goulash of moods, from farce to teen
comedy to drama. Con and caper movies usually result in one of two
resolutions. Everyone involved loses in the end, even if they pull
off the con, because we realize that all of life is a con (House
of Games). Or, in the conventional happy ending, the good con
artists pull one over on the bad guys and slip away happily ever
after (Ocean's Eleven, The Sting). Matchstick
Men flirts with the former and then chickens out with a happy ending
that it never earns and that the audience doesn't feel like participating
in. Or is the point that Nicolas Cage's character doesn't care if
it was all a game--he'd rather go back to his delusions because
they cured him of his obsessive compulsive disorder?
Alison Lohman is quite good. Good year for teen
actresses with Lohman, Evan Rachel Wood from Thirteen,
and Scarlet Johansson from Lost in Translation killing
it on the big screen. Nicolas Cage does his crazy man routine, which
seems fun in measured doses and becomes tiresome when stretched
out, like the friend who doesn't know when to cut off some impression
at a cocktail party because he's cracking himself up so much. And
then he spills wine all over the carpet and everyone is mortified. |
| All
the Real Girls (2003) |
 |
David Gordon Green's ability to find the sublime
and beautiful in small town life worked better when the characters
were the young children of George Washington. When the subject
is puppy love among wayward rural twenty somethings, one can't help
feeling that Green is going too easy on them. Still, Green seeks out
unconventional and natural scenes and dialogue to paint his emotional
palette, and his movies wash over viewers with the soothing, pleasing
benevolence of a watercolor. |
| So Close
(2003) |
 |
Hey, turns out Hong Kong can still crank out
fun action like nobody's business. It's not just that the choreography
is top notch (director Cory Yuen is another in a long line of HK
industry vets tapped by Hollywood for action choreography), but
HK action movies are unabashedly unironic. An American audience
might laugh derisively at the goofy slapstick and tragicomic sentimentality,
but it's more likely they'll be dazzled by Shu Qi in her gorgeous
designer white pantsuit and designer sunglasses, blowing away bodyguards
while hanging upside down from the ceiling, suspended by a retractable
spike emerging from one of her stiletto heels.
Leaving aside the bad subtitles (English subtitlers
of Asian movies are like airport security screening personnel pre
9/11; underpaid and ineffective), you'll laugh through most of this
movie from pleasure. |
| Lost
in Translation (2003) |
 |
Sofia Coppola has the visual eye of a street photographer
and the most consummate taste in acting, cinematography, and music.
Bill Murray is brilliant, Scarlet Johansson is amazing. A stylistic
mood piece, infused with humanity and emotion by its two leads. It's
pitch perfect and the best movie of 2003 to date. |
| The
School of Rock (2003) |
 |
Jack Black releasing his inner child helps to distract
us from the other more lousy child acting in this movie. This is Black
in a mainstream commercial comedy, but somehow he still manages to
retain his signature comedic style, even if his language is tempered.
Even commercially diluted Jack Black is worth an evening of chuckles,
especially when he's discussing one of his favorite topics: rock'n
roll. |
|
|
Movie Links
Adjusted historical
box office figures.
Problems with the Academy Award's Best Foreign-Language film award.
A cryptic, visually derivative trailer for
a Japanese sci-fi movie. Where is the subtitled version? UPDATE: Someone has seen Casshern!
Do critics actually matter? This article claims to find a correlation
between the number of stars a movie receives and its box office. The
usual post hoc, ergo propter hoc disclaimers apply.
Martin Scorsese and Leonardo Dicaprio to remake
the Infernal Affairs trilogy? Good article on
the state of American acting.
Movie reviews
by the Pope.
A compilation of
approximately 200 movie critic top 10 lists for 2003. Here it is in tabular
form.
Movies I'm looking forward to...
- Innocence: Ghost
in the Shell 2 (Spring 2004
in Japan): Mamoru Oshii's Ghost in the Shell was one of the most influential
and brilliant anime movies ever made.
- Steamboy (Jul 17 in Japan): the next anime movie from Katsuhiro Ôtomo of Akira fame. Trailer here.
- The
Life Aquatic (Fall
2004): Let's examine the talent involved. Wes Anderson, Bill
Murray, Owen Wilson, Cate Blanchett, Willem Dafoe, Henry
Selick...good Lord.
- The
Incredibles (Nov 5): Pixar's next computer-animated tale.
- Alexander (Nov
2004): Oliver Stone's take on the original Great One.
- Ocean's
Twelve (Dec 12):
Soderbergh directs the followup to Ocean's Eleven,
a wonderfully fun flick itself. This time, the heists are in
London, and Vincent Cassel joins the cast.
- The Aviator (Dec
17): Leonardo DiCaprio continues to tackle famous historical
figures by playing Howard Hughes in Martin Scorsese's next project.
- Izô:
Kaosu mataha fujôri
no kijin (?
2004): Takashi Miike directing Takeshi Kitano?! In. I think the title
means "Sweet Ass-Kicking Samurai Movie."
- Batman Begins (2005):
Christian Bale will be Batman, and the director is Christopher Nolan
(Memento).
- Inglorious Bastards (2004-2005?)):
after Kill Bill, possibly Tarantino's next project, a WWII flick.
- Alexander
the Great (2004/2005/2006??):
Leonardo DiCaprio is the Great One in Baz Luhrmann's massive
production.
- King Kong (2005/2006?):
Can't wait to see how Peter Jackson reimagines the King Kong story
and how he uses New Zealand.
- 2046
(TBD): The next film by Wong Kar Wai, one of the great directors working
today. Cast is to include all his favorite folks: Takuya Kimura,
Tony
Leung, Carina Lau, Faye Wong and Rosamond Kwan. That's not all, Zhang
Ziyi will join the cast also. A bit more wacky are rumors that
he may get Brad Pitt?! Wong Kar Wai does sci-fi. HOT.
- Indiana Jones 4 (Jul 5, 2005): Spielberg to produce,
an older Harrison Ford to star. Kate Capshaw, Spielberg's wife, will
co-star. Frank Darabont (The Shawshank Redemption, The
Green Mile) to write.
Best place to buy movies online (yes, I'm biased) is Amazon.com.
|